Labor Rights Violations: 17 Broken Promises By Apple And Its Chinese Suppliers

Steven Millward
1:47 pm on Jul 29, 2013

How long does it take for endemic and institutional problems to be solved? Judging from numerous reports on labor rights violations at Apple’s various China suppliers, it takes years for minute improvements to be made. But, as today’s newest investigation from China Labor Watch (CLW) shows, these reports are as grim as ever.

The new CLW report looks at three Pegatron factories (Pegatron Shanghai, Riteng in Shanghai, and AVY in Suzhou) that are key Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) suppliers and finds ongoing labor abuses – such as excessive work hours above China’s legal limit; pregnant women forced to quit for their own well-being; underage labor from local vocational colleges – and other wrongdoings like environmental pollution.

17 Labor Rights Violations Still Found at One Apple Supplier in China, 2013

Of course, other companies should shoulder the blame as well. Some of those Pegatron facilities are also producing for Nokia, Panasonic, HP, Dell, Asus, Acer, and Sony.

Rather than summarizing the whole report, let’s look at the section called ‘Apple’s 17 promises versus 17 realities’.

1. Apple: We limit work weeks to 60 hours

But CLW notes:

At the three Pegatron factories that CLW investigated, weekly working hours for the majority of production workers were about 66, 67, and 69 hours, respectively. When orders were being rushed, these hours were even longer and workers seldom received a day off. China’s legal limit is 49 hours per week.

2. Apple: All overtime must be voluntary

But, in reality, “if a worker chooses one time not to accept scheduled overtime, the factory will not provide her an opportunity to do any overtime work for the entire month as punishment.” Many workers rely on having some overtime to boost the meagre wages.

“Hourly wages for workers producing Apple products (between $1.30 and $1.50) are not high enough to meet basic needs. For example, in Shanghai, China’s most expensive city, where the average wage is $764, workers at Pegatron only earn $268 before overtime.”

3. Apple: We don’t tolerate underage labor

In reality, rampant corruption, especially between Chinese factory bosses and vocational schools, sees student “interns” required to work at the factories.

4. Excessive use of third-party labor agents

“In each of the three Pegatron Group subsidiaries factories, there was a heavy reliance on third-party labor agents — i.e., dispatch labor companies — to hire workers.” Some facilities recruit 50 percent of workers in this way. But an upcoming Chinese law will limit that to 10 percent at each facility. But that presumes the law will be enforced.

5. Apple: We require all of our suppliers to compensate workers for any illegal deductions and wage deficiencies

“Each of the three factories we investigated had unpaid overtime violations in which they did not compensate workers for daily 15- to 30-minute meetings, adding up to 7 to 14 hours of unpaid overtime per worker per month.”

6. Suppliers still doing discriminatory screening for medical conditions or pregnancy

The Pegatron factories had a list of discriminatory hiring practices, including refusing to hire people shorter than 4 foot 11 inches tall, pregnant women, those older than 35, people with tattoos, or people of the Hui, Tibetan, or Uighur ethnic groups. Not that it justifies this, but many companies in China – including foreign companies operating in the country – practice discriminatory screening as well.

7. Apple: Excessive recruitment fees and bonded labor are strictly prohibited

But these are still widespread at the investigated facilities.

8. Apple: We require suppliers to implement Apple-designed training programs to educate workers about their rights

Apple CEO Tim Cook tours Foxconn's Zhengzhou iPhone plant in March 2012 [Image source: Bloomberg]

Apple CEO Tim Cook tours Foxconn’s Zhengzhou iPhone plant in March 2012 [Image source: Bloomberg]

Sadly, this well-intentioned training is done badly by factory management.

9. Ineffective or threatening management

“Pegatron supervisors harassed and abused workers by swearing at them and threatening collective punishment. If workers at AVY did not finish 600 iPad back covers during a single shift, they would be made to stay late without wages and accept scolding in front of others.”

10. Apple: Our suppliers must follow strict standards when hiring students

Sadly, many high-school age students are required to work at the factories despite the production work being unrelated to their studies. This is something we’ve also written about at Foxconn, which is another major supplier to Apple and other big-name western tech brands.

11. Apple: Workers have a right to be in an environment where they can voice their concerns freely

You’ve guessed it: this is not happening in practice.

12. Protective gear and safety kit

Even basic equipment like masks are not being used in many cases.

13. Apple: We are committed to worker well-being

However, the report notes: “Pregnant women making Apple products at these factories cannot take maternity leave if they became pregnant out of wedlock or if they are having a second child outside of China’s family planning policies. This inability to take leave forces mothers to make a choice between their baby and their job.”

In addition, over-crowding at dorms leaves workers waiting hours to take a shower. Eight to 12 workers are crammed into one room.

14. Apple: It is critical that both suppliers and Apple employees are prepared to identify hazards

But things like first-aid kits and fire escapes and drills are found to be lacking.

15. Apple: We do not tolerate environmental violations of any kind

The report’s investigators discovered industrial wastewater being directly poured into the sewage system that then led to local waterways.

16. Apple: An Apple auditor leads every onsite audit

“Audits often overlook labor violations because factories make preparations ahead of time. Pegatron, for example, forces workers to sign falsified attendance records which detail overtime hours at sometimes half the number of actual overtime hours worked.”

17. Apple: We forbid disciplinary pay deductions in any country

However, things like failing to eat at predetermined times, and absence from unpaid meetings, can all lead to fines.

The full CLW report is here in PDF form.

(Editing by Anh-Minh Do)

  • Mike

    This post is damning China, not Apple. If your suggestion is that Apple should dip into that mountain of cash and buy up their entire supply chain (which is pretty much their plan), I’m not sure that makes China look very good.

    So you’re saying if International Companies (in this case, the richest tech company on Earth) want to use China as their manufacturing base, there is literally nothing they can do to control standards, practices and human rights violations (to speak nothing of any IP theft which is the number one risk associated with Chinese business)?

    And you think that makes Tim Cook look bad? Or China look bad?

    Would you rather just re-title this article about ‘Pegatron’ or keep insisting this is really a story about Apple? ( I know, hits. I got it.)

  • sigs

    Mike: because it IS about Apple. Apple lying and deliberately smoothing over gaping and criminal practices. Lying to consumers so they would feel better about using their hipster products or whatever.

    No news that labor conditions are abominable in China. News is (as sub-header breakdown might tell you, have you actually read the story) that Apple is lying. Though I’m not quite sure that qualifies as news either.

  • mike

    As I said, if Apple owned the factory, I would be on board. This isn’t an Apple story, it’s a Pegatron story. At some level, neither you or I know the truth, but Apple technically does not own the factory. As such, there is only so much they can do to ‘enforce’ their ‘Western practices’. Pegatron’s problem (which they richly enjoy by the way!) is still a China problem.

    As Steven himself writes, “Sadly, this well-intentioned training is done badly by factory management.” That pretty much covers the whole reform program.

  • chinese workers

    我是中国工人,感谢你们的关注,中国劳工!世界工人,相互理解和支持,共同推动中国工运的发展;推动中国工会的改革;希望我们在,国际劳工,国际工会,表达我们共同的心愿!I am Chinese workers, thank you for your concern, China labor! The world workers, understand and support each other, work together to promote the development of Chinese labor movement; to promote the reform of Chinese trade unions; we hope in, international labor, International Union, expression of our common aspiration!

  • chinese workers

    By my page and let the world see the real Chinese workers, working life and struggle!
    My website, reported that Chinese workers.Because I am Chinese workers, union members, re-employment of workers, trade unions, workers.

    I visit the websites and post comments with the assistance of machine translation.
    I am using Google Translate. If the translation is not accurate, please refer to Chinese as the standard. In order to avoid misunderstanding. Thank you, friends!

Read More