Meta has filed a motion for judgment in its ongoing antitrust trial.

The company claims the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has not provided sufficient evidence to prove it unlawfully monopolized the social networking market.

The FTC’s case focuses on Meta’s acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp, alleging that these actions stifled competition.

In its filing, submitted after the FTC rested its case, Meta argues that the agency has not met the legal standards required under antitrust law.

The court has not yet ruled on Meta’s motion, and trial proceedings are ongoing.

🔗 Source: The Verge

🧠 Food for thought

1️⃣ Antitrust precedents show historical pattern of tech giants defending market definitions

Meta’s dispute over the “personal social networking services” market definition follows a pattern seen in landmark tech antitrust cases over decades.

In the 1990s Microsoft case, the company similarly argued against the government’s market definition of PC operating systems, claiming it faced robust competition beyond just Windows competitors 1.

This definitional battle proved crucial in the Microsoft case outcome, which ultimately created space for companies like Google to emerge while Microsoft was distracted by litigation 2.

The challenge of defining relevant markets has become increasingly complex in digital ecosystems, where network effects create powerful advantages for incumbents and traditional market boundaries blur 1.

Meta’s emphasis on competition from TikTok reflects how tech companies consistently frame markets broadly when facing antitrust scrutiny 2.

Legal history shows these definitional disputes often determine case outcomes, with courts sometimes accepting narrower market definitions than companies prefer, as happened when Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson ruled against Microsoft’s broader market interpretation 1.

2️⃣ Tech antitrust cases carry significant business consequences beyond legal outcomes

Historical evidence shows that regardless of legal outcomes, prolonged antitrust battles create substantial business challenges for the targeted companies.

Recent Meta developments